Introduction

Buying a mattress online feels like a gamble—until you understand trial periods. These risk-free windows let you sleep on your new mattress for weeks or even a full year before committing. But not all trials are created equal. Some brands make returns effortless with free pickup, while others bury fees in the fine print or require you to "break in" the mattress for weeks before you can return it.

We analyzed sleep trials from 15 major mattress brands, examining trial length, return policies, hidden costs, and real customer experiences. Our goal: help you find a mattress you can genuinely test without worrying about getting stuck with an expensive mistake.

Our methodology: We evaluated each brand on four criteria—trial duration, mandatory break-in periods, return logistics (free pickup vs. self-arranged), and any restocking or return fees. We also factored in customer reviews mentioning the return process and consulted guidelines from the Better Business Bureau regarding mattress return complaints.

Quick Comparison

Here's how the top mattress brands stack up on trial period terms. This overview helps you quickly identify which companies offer the most consumer-friendly policies.

Brand Trial Length Break-In Period Free Returns Restocking Fee
Nectar 365 nights 30 days Yes None
DreamCloud 365 nights 30 days Yes None
Casper 100 nights 30 days Yes None
Purple 100 nights 21 days Yes None
Saatva 365 nights None Yes* $99 fee
Helix 100 nights 30 days Yes None
Leesa 100 nights 30 days Yes None
Tempur-Pedic 90 nights 30 days Yes $175 fee
Avocado 365 nights 30 days Yes None
Brooklyn Bedding 120 nights 30 days Yes None

*Saatva offers free "white glove" pickup but charges a $99 return transportation fee, which is important to factor into your decision.

Best Overall: Nectar

Nectar leads our rankings with a full 365-night trial period and genuinely hassle-free returns. This combination of extended testing time and zero fees makes it the gold standard for risk-free mattress shopping.

Pros
  • Industry-leading 365-night trial
  • No restocking or return fees
  • Free pickup and full refund
  • Forever warranty included
Cons
  • 30-day mandatory break-in period
  • Memory foam may sleep warm for some
  • Limited firmness options

Nectar's return process is straightforward: contact customer service after the 30-day break-in period, schedule a free pickup, and receive a full refund within a few business days. The company donates or recycles returned mattresses, which aligns with growing consumer interest in sustainable practices. According to Sleep Foundation reviews, Nectar's return experience consistently receives positive marks from customers who needed to use it.

Best Budget Option: DreamCloud

DreamCloud matches Nectar's 365-night trial while offering a luxury hybrid mattress at a lower price point. If you want maximum testing time without a premium price tag, DreamCloud delivers exceptional value.

Pros
  • 365-night trial matches industry best
  • Hybrid construction at budget-friendly price
  • No return fees or shipping costs
  • Lifetime warranty
Cons
  • 30-day break-in required before returns
  • Heavier mattress can be difficult to move
  • Frequent sales make "regular" pricing unclear

DreamCloud frequently runs promotions that drop prices significantly below MSRP, making this an excellent choice for budget-conscious shoppers who still want a lengthy, pressure-free trial. The return process mirrors Nectar's (both brands are owned by Resident Home), with free pickup arranged through customer service.

Best Premium Option: Saatva

Saatva stands out in the premium segment with a 365-night trial and no mandatory break-in period—you can return anytime within the first year if it's not right for you. However, the $99 return transportation fee is an important consideration.

Pros
  • 365-night trial with no break-in requirement
  • White glove delivery and setup included
  • Old mattress removal available
  • Multiple firmness levels and mattress types
Cons
  • $99 return transportation fee
  • Higher base price than competitors
  • No bed-in-a-box convenience

The $99 fee is Saatva's only drawback, but context matters: their white glove service includes in-home setup and old mattress removal, which adds genuine value. For shoppers investing in a premium mattress, the fee is a reasonable trade-off for the convenience and extended trial window. Saatva's innerspring construction also appeals to those who prefer traditional mattress feel over all-foam options.

Best for Quick Decisions: Purple

Purple offers a 100-night trial with a shorter 21-day break-in period, making it ideal for shoppers who know relatively quickly whether a mattress works for them. The unique GelFlex Grid technology is distinctive enough that most people form an opinion within the first few weeks.

Pros
  • Shortest break-in period (21 days)
  • Unique pressure-relieving grid technology
  • Completely free returns with pickup
  • Temperature-neutral sleep surface
Cons
  • Shorter 100-night trial window
  • Unusual feel isn't for everyone
  • Higher price point for grid models

Purple's grid technology creates a love-it-or-know-quickly experience. The shorter break-in period respects this reality—if the feel isn't clicking after three weeks, it probably won't. Returns are handled through scheduling a free pickup, and refunds process quickly according to customer feedback.

Best for Eco-Conscious Shoppers: Avocado

Avocado Green Mattress combines a 365-night trial with certified organic materials and carbon-negative manufacturing. For environmentally conscious shoppers, this represents both risk-free testing and values-aligned purchasing.

Pros
  • Full year trial period
  • GOTS and GOLS certified organic materials
  • No return fees
  • B-Corp certified company
Cons
  • 30-day break-in requirement
  • Premium pricing for organic materials
  • Heavier than foam alternatives

Avocado arranges free return pickup and donates returned mattresses to charitable organizations whenever possible. The combination of extended trial period, ethical manufacturing, and zero return fees makes this an excellent choice for shoppers prioritizing sustainability without sacrificing consumer protections.

How We Tested

Our evaluation process focused on the policies themselves rather than mattress comfort, since comfort is subjective and the whole point of a trial period is discovering what works for you.

0 of 5 completed 0%

  • We documented the exact number of nights offered and whether any conditions shortened the effective window.

  • We confirmed mandatory wait times before returns are accepted, which effectively reduces your risk-free window.

  • We identified all potential costs including restocking fees, return shipping, and pickup charges buried in terms of service.

  • We evaluated whether returns require self-arranged donation, company pickup, or third-party logistics.

  • We analyzed reviews specifically mentioning return experiences to identify gaps between policy and practice.

We weighted fee-free returns and simplified logistics heavily in our rankings. A 365-night trial means less if the return process involves finding a local charity, arranging pickup, and providing donation receipts—steps some brands still require.

FAQ

Most reputable brands donate returned mattresses to charitable organizations, recycle materials, or resell them through outlet channels at a discount. Companies like Nectar, Casper, and Avocado have established donation partnerships. This approach addresses the environmental concerns around mattress trials while maintaining generous return policies.

Break-in periods serve two purposes: they allow your body to adjust to a new sleep surface (which genuinely takes time) and they reduce frivolous returns from customers who never intended to keep the mattress. Most sleep experts agree that 2-4 weeks is reasonable for your body to adapt, though 30 days is on the longer end of that range.

Policies vary significantly. Most brands require mattresses to be in "good condition" but accept normal use. Significant stains, tears, or damage typically void the return policy. Using a mattress protector from day one protects both your investment and your return eligibility—it's essentially required if you want to preserve your options.

Usually yes, but always verify. Most major brands honor the same trial period regardless of purchase price or promotional discounts. However, outlet purchases, floor models, and third-party retailer purchases may have different terms. Buy directly from the manufacturer's website when trial terms matter to you.

Trial periods let you return a mattress you don't like for a full refund—it's about comfort preference. Warranties cover manufacturing defects like sagging, broken coils, or material breakdown over time. A 10-year warranty won't help if you simply don't like how the mattress feels; that's what the trial period is for.

Conclusion

The best mattress trial period depends on your priorities. For maximum flexibility with zero risk, Nectar and DreamCloud both offer 365-night trials with completely free returns. Budget-conscious shoppers should lean toward DreamCloud, while those wanting a proven track record might prefer Nectar's slightly longer market presence.

Saatva is our premium pick for shoppers who value white glove service and no break-in requirements, despite the $99 return fee. And Purple makes sense for decisive shoppers who want the shortest break-in period and a unique sleep experience.

Regardless of which brand you choose, always read the complete terms of service before purchasing, use a mattress protector from night one, and document any issues with photos if you do need to initiate a return. A generous trial period only protects you if you understand and follow the rules.

365
Longest Trial (nights)
Nectar, DreamCloud, Saatva, Avocado
$0
Best Return Fee
Most brands offer fee-free returns
21-30
Typical Break-In (days)
Required before return eligibility